NFL Football on

Where Vikings fans skol!


Are Vikings Fans Already Questioning Toby Gerhart?

July 14, 2011 by Nick in CONTROVERSY
It may seem like it’s not that big of a deal considering Adrian Peterson’s phenomenal talent, but the Minnesota Vikings desperately need a quality backup running back that can provide the offense with a change of pace and give Peterson a chance to catch his breath. Although Toby Gerhert’s 2010 rookie season left something to be desired, don’t count him out as Peterson’s potential wingman.

After they lost backup running back Chester Taylor(notes) to the Chicago Bears last year, rookie running back Toby Gerhart(notes) out of Stanford was expected to take his place. The Vikings were so confident in his abilities that they traded up in the second round to make sure that he ended up in purple and gold. Unfortunately, his rookie year didn’t pan out quite as well as they had hoped for.

What the Vikings missed in 2010 was a running back of Taylor’s caliber and experience to help spell Peterson and keep the opposing defenses on their toes. Taylor was a huge asset as a third-down back in 2009, but left Minnesota in hopes of earning a starting spot in Chicago (Matt Forte(notes) had other plans). That’s not to say that Gerhart isn’t a talented and versatile running back, but he hasn’t yet reached that level where he can properly compliment a superstar like Peterson. More than anything, he hasn’t yet adjusted to the speed and physicality of the NFL.

Throughout his career at Stanford, Gerhart made a living out of bulldozing defenders and picking up yards after contact. Now that he’s in the NFL, doing the things that made him the Heisman Trophy runner-up in 2009 hasn’t been as effective.


The 2010 NFL season saw him get off to a slow start. He looked lost like a freshman walking around campus on the first day of high school. However, as he got more familiar with his surroundings and started receiving more reps while Peterson rested, things started to click. Apart from a few fumbles, he picked up his yards-per-carry average in the second half of the season and even scored his first NFL rushing touchdown against the Washington Redskins.

His most impressive game of the year came against the Chicago Bears during Week 15. On 16 carries, he racked up 77 yards for a 4.8 yards-per-carry average, including a 21-yard scamper. He also caught three passes for 18 yards. Despite his fumble in the game, he ran strong and showed good vision when the offense put the ball in his hands.

By season’s end, Gerhart had tallied 322 yards on 81 carries (four yards-per-carry) while scoring one touchdown. He also caught 21 passes for 167 yards as he tried to fill the Vikings’ third-down back role. He has room for improvement in that role, but the 13 first downs he picked up throughout the seasn are promising. Despite some struggles in the pass blocking department, he has the strength and size to become an effective protector as he continues to grow comfortable with the NFL’s speed.

Read the rest of the article at Yahoo


Toby Gerhart raised some issues in the draft last year for being a ‘white running back’.  Surprisingly it caused enough of a stir to cause him to fall to the Vikings in the second round.   I imagine the fans that aren’t happy with his production are unfairly comparing him to NFL phenom Adrian Peterson.  Petereson is such a rare talent that its simply unfair to expect that type of productivity out of both your backs.  Gerhart is a solid third back down that is needed to spell Peterson and gain short yards.  Assuming he works on his pass blocking Gerhart will continue to add value to this team for years.


  1. daniel tylerAugust 5, 2011 at 7:08 pm

    Umm…he became productive when they actually gave him the ball. And what the hell is up with running him out of the fullback spot with Percy in the tailback spot, they haven’t run Percy out of that formation one single time, he just screams “toby gerhart fb dive” hes 3 yards away from the line of scrimmage, the line doesn’t have time to create crease, he doesn’t have time to pick a hole or even bounce it to the outside if the inside is clogged up,this is how he was used for most of the Redskins game, even the td he scored. There was one play where he did go backwards on a fullback dive after the lane was clogged up and gain positive yards. They are treating him like he is just a straight line runner. His big run was when they finally ran the stretch play, coincidentally the 21 yard run he had in preseason was the only stretch play they had him run. You just can’t use Gerhart on inside zone and fullback dives, of course he isn’t going to average a high ypc, mix it up. 2 games where he got significant touches, the 1st game he did okay, the 2nd game he looked solid. Im sure if he wouldve had a 3rd game it wouldve been 100+ yards.

    Did you see him adjust to that pass against the Packers and make that guy miss in space?

  2. Ryan McBarronAugust 6, 2011 at 10:42 pm

    Chester Taylor averaged a ridiculously atrocious 2.8 yards per carry last year (I admit that the Bears run blocking is bad, but come on that’s pitiful). I’d rather have a younger Toby with much more upside. Toby outproduced 1st round picks C.J Spiller and Jahvid Best in efficiency as a rookie (YPC and via footballoutsiders DVOR and DVOA stats) and was just behind Ryan Matthews. The one area that Toby must work on is ball security. Peterson had some problems with this too in years past. I have a good feeling about Gerhart this year, he just needs some confidence and more reps to figure things out.

Recent Posts
  • Ben Tate – Still Not A Featured Back
  • Vikings Finding Diamonds In The Rough
  • Griffen Making Spielman Look Smart… Twice
  • Vikings Need A Standout Tall Receiver
  • Vikings Need To Go To Banyard